Tuesday, December 4, 2007

Shi Shi Ling Long Ti Wan Po

Betsy was getting ready to go to an Oriental ball. She realized that she didnt have a dress to wear. She borrowed a dress from her friends Shi Shi Ling Long Ti Wan Po. As Betsy puts on the dress, it rips.

Is she obligated to pay for a new dress?

-If the dress was already ripped, she doesn't have to pay for it.

-Maybe she didnt know the dress was ripped.

-Maybe Betsy was to big for the dress, so she ripped it.

With Love,

Alexa and Hallie

20 comments:

Anonymous said...

she definitely has to pay for it because she ripped it

Hallie said...

but what if the dress was already ripped and her friend didnt tell her about it? maybe her friend wanted her to look bad or be imbarraced at the ball!

Julie said...

i agree w/max. if she was the one who ripped it, then she is obligated. but what if the dress was ripped in the first place and the person who lent it to her knew it, but she wanted the other person to rip it then pay for it?

Hallie said...

Exactly my point julie

seth said...

No matter what the owner of the dress should pay because she needs to take responsibility for her possesions.

Jake and Seth

linkin paak foreva said...

She would have to pay because she ripped it and it was her fault.

Hallie said...

Well it is not her fault if the dress was already dripped!

E Palte said...

Well if it were already rip wouldn't then Shi Shi Ling Long Ti Wan Po should have told Betsy, and then if it were ripped when Betsy got it, and she ripped it more, then she pays for what she did.

michael L said...

rabbi t-pain says if she was 2 fat then it would b kinda mean to make her pay by saying "b/c of your fatness u ripped my dress pay up"
but if she like fell while she was putting it on then its ok to make her pay $

ML
WH

Anonymous said...

actually if they are good friends then they should split the cost of the dress

Evan W. said...

rabbi johan says that she is obligated to pay the damages unless shi shi whateva her name is knew it was ripped before hand

Sarah Q said...

But what would happen if she ripped it on purpose?

linkin paak foreva said...

she has to pay b/c she made it rip

carmelle said...

she has to pay..because before it was in good shape when she recieved it and then it ripped...so she is guilty

Hallie said...

Rabbitson Hallie says that you are probably right it is the girl who ripped the drwesses fault

Ari said...

Betsy must pay, she ripped it

Yael Dosetareh said...

She has to pay bec she ripped it. And i love HALLIE and ALEXA!! OMG im no excited for Basketball today!!

Cayley S. said...

She has to pay for it because she ripped it

Cayley S. said...

She has to pay for it because she ripped it

chez*ler said...

she ripped it so she has to pay for it. if it was already ripped and her friend was just trying to make her look bad then she should find better friends.